25 Comments
User's avatar
Hannah 🍌's avatar

My favorite thing about the lizard review is when you say β€œI can’t get into it” and then proceed to very much get into it. Brava!

Expand full comment
Madeline Rubicam's avatar

LMFAGJREIOGJERIOGAJRIGOJ WELL YES!!!

Expand full comment
Tiffany's avatar

The lack of tears on THIS PARTICULAR EPISODE is sending me.

Expand full comment
Madeline Rubicam's avatar

I was dry as a bone. Literally not a tear in the house I cried it all out

Expand full comment
Anna's avatar

Monstro elisasue mentioned ⁉️⁉️⁉️

Expand full comment
Shravya's avatar

I saw a reddit comment that said an informal name for Lupus in the medical community is "The Great Masquerader" or "The Great Imitator" because it mimics the symptoms of lots of other diseases. So her tying the theme of her chronic illness with her shapeshifting sensibilities is MUAHHHHH *chefs kisss* she's actually so clever it's so unfortunate she comes across as cringe to the unwashed masses because she's one of those artists whose going to stand the test of time IMO

Expand full comment
Madeline Rubicam's avatar

OMFGGG THAT’S SO COOL….I DID NOT KNOW THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Expand full comment
Liz's avatar

You cannot convince me that the only living girl in LA isn’t a riff on the only living boy in NY by Simon and Garfunkel.

Expand full comment
Pluto's avatar

I AM SAT!!!

Expand full comment
Chloe et al.?'s avatar

I'm sat like I've never sat before OMG

Expand full comment
India Melly's avatar

Where is the analysis of I never loved you?

Expand full comment
Madeline Rubicam's avatar

You mean ARSONIST!

Expand full comment
India Melly's avatar

GAGGED for that 😻 but you skipped over INLY cause you already spoke about it but I can’t find where !!

Expand full comment
Madeline Rubicam's avatar

It was in one of my new music Sunday episodes I think though I sincerely cannot remember which LMFAO!!

Expand full comment
Megan's avatar

Loved your reaction on the Patreon and this deeper analysis as well. Dog Years and Arsonist were immediate stand outs to me! Definitely need more time to percolate on the album as a whole

Expand full comment
Ria Skyer's avatar

Thank you for this episode Madeline! You are the perfect person to tackle this album (but we knew this)!

What did you think of the images recreating Bruce Springsteen and Aaliyah?

Expand full comment
Madeline Rubicam's avatar

Well the tea of it all is that I accidentally called Bruce Springsteen Billy Joel so I had to edit it out 😭 I was like you know I could just make a note that I meant to say Bruce Spingsteen but idk if I can bear the humiliation so let’s just pretend that didn’t happen……………

Expand full comment
SW's avatar

I haven’t listened yet, I’m moving and don’t have time. Will catch up later. But I did listen to the album yesterday and loved it. I know you probably did too. I’ve also done a complete 180 on lucky after the contest of the entire album. I thinks it’s a great song. Does anyone else hear the Monica Angel of Mine sample on it? Is she credited? Idk πŸ€·πŸ½β€β™€οΈ can’t wait to listen Lizard! Happy Halsey week everybody!

Expand full comment
SW's avatar

Context

Expand full comment
ashley's avatar

I LOVED the title track bc it sounds like a theater kid song and really framed the album as a play for me. Especially with the interludes; They feel like they denote the acts of the play and Letter to God I is a demented I Want song.

Expand full comment
Laney's avatar

I'm not going to be able to talk about this album for while, so I'm grateful you're pushing through to talk about it. Also, the critics are LOVING it AS. THEY. SHOULD.

Expand full comment
Ritwik Upadhyay's avatar

Loved the album.

Loved this review even more.

Thankyou so much!!!😊

Expand full comment
Ritwik Upadhyay's avatar

You’re so right!!!

This album can’t be digested in just one listen.

It has layers and will take time to understand

Expand full comment
Alex Zalar's avatar

SOOOOOOO SEATED I’ve been needing this!!!

Expand full comment
Chloe's avatar

ngl i LOVED this album on first listen but most songs (especially dog years, life of the spider, and hurt feelings) make me so nauseous that i might not be able to listen to it very often 😭 wishing her happiness and good health for the rest of her life, chronic illness is fucking awful

Expand full comment