18 Comments

I was with you on the tropical Christmas hate train until you started speaking about my Queen Mele Kalikimaka, she’s different

Expand full comment

Have you heard the new Laufey Christmas EP? I think it’s super cute.

Expand full comment

My hot take is that the song from the Polar Express is one of the best Christmas songs but nobody will admit it because they’re scared of the CGI people lol. But I swear it gets me every time 🥲

Expand full comment

The way I’ve NEVERRRR seen that movie LMFAO!! I should check it out….

Expand full comment

Patti LaBelle!

Expand full comment

Lol as someone who grew up in Miami I had no choice but to embrace tropical Christmas. I have never seen snow on Christmas so I must imagine. We have to pretend Madeline!!! Pretending is all we have!!! We have no choice!!!!

I love mele kalikimaka 😭

(All comments on ella fitzgerald are correct… icon)

Expand full comment

Also i recommend some r&b christmas! Alicia Keys, Luther Vandross, Brandy, and Coco Jones all have great Christmas albums

I also love Destiny’s Child song 8 Days of Christmas (havent heard the whole album)

Expand full comment

COCO JONES?!?!?!!?!?! NOW WE’RE COOKING………………..

Expand full comment

So the song just for now is in the Xmas film ‘the holiday’ which is what I guess makes it an Xmas song!

Expand full comment

oh period. I need to rewatch that EXPEDITIOUSLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Expand full comment

You definately do - one of my faves!

Expand full comment

We’re so different loll I’m in South Carolina crying because it’s below 50 and you’re complaining it’s too warm. 😭

Expand full comment

I don’t think anything could have prepared me for the lyrics to A Cheer for the Elves

Expand full comment

IT’S SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO……………………….I MEAN REALLY!?!?!?!?!?!!?!? SHE’S A GROWN WOMANNNNN

Expand full comment

i feel like girl in red might be an artist that you don’t gravitate toward, but as a queer person she has a lot of nice songs that hit different. her song “two queens in a king sized bed” is one of my favorite modern christmas songs. it’s very jingly and sweet and simple. i’d recommend checking it out. and if you do like girl in red, i have other non-christmas song recs for you 🧑‍🎄

Expand full comment

On a separate note, I have to ask if you have seen The Magnificent Ambersons (Orsin Welles)? Two reasons I’m asking…one is your use of the word Comeuppance and two is that I noticed it on the movie theater marquee in a Gilmore Girls rewatch. It’s so amazing, and it has Endora when she was young as well as one of the best sleigh ride scenes ever.

Expand full comment

I’ve never seen that before!!!!!!! I should check it out

Expand full comment

Madeline, I love hearing your take on different Christmas music. Have you ever listened to The Roches Xmas album The Three Kings? It has two *original* songs they wrote that are both in my Christmas Top Ten, with Star of Wonder being my all time fave. The second is called Christmas Passing Through which is one of those songs that creates a specific feeling. Harmonies are out of this world bc they are three sisters. The whole album is superb!! Also EmmyLou Harris Light of the Stable has a few great ones, esp the opening track Christmas Times a-Comin’ (the dulcimer and mandolin are fantastic). Jane Siberry has a live album “Child” with a song “Neighbor, Neighbor” which is so witty and funny (Quoi, Ma Voisine, Es-Tu Fachee?)). Finally, Grover Washington Jr’s version of Breath of Heaven is my fave version of that one (vocals by Lisa Fisher). Merry Christmas, Baby (Bruce Springsteen)!!!

Expand full comment